Creamy, pigmented, and huge for the money — just don't skip the setting powder.
Strong pigment and a huge pan of product for under $20 — but it's oil-based, needs setting powder, and the reds stain. What 13,400+ buyer reviews reveal.
At $17.99 (as of August 2026), the Athena palette is the budget pick for Halloween, stage, and cosplay — big pans, strong pigment, months of use. The catch is technique. It's oil-based, so setting powder is mandatory, and the reds will outstay their welcome on skin. Buyers who treat it like cream makeup love it; buyers who expect water-activated paint don't.
**The Three-Star Reviews Are a Prep Problem**
Sort the ratings and a split shows up fast. The five-star crowd — 73% — talks pigment and quantity: one layer covers, five full looks barely dent the pans, months of use without hitting bottom. The three-star crowd talks smudging. Both describe the same paint. The difference is prep.
**It's Oil Paint, and That Decides Everything**
This is not water-activated aqua makeup, and buyers who treat it that way struggle — water won't thin it, details smear, layers turn to mud. Handle it like cream makeup and the story flips: one cosplayer logged four smudge-free hours in costume after locking it down with HD setting powder, and another buyer's look held through a hot evening under translucent powder. The powder isn't optional. It's the whole trick.
**Red Is the Last Thing to Leave**
Staining complaints cluster on red and pink — anything from a faint day-after shadow to one buyer spending two hours getting red off around the eyes. Coconut oil or a cleansing balm speeds the job; most of the other 18 shades rinse off with regular cleanser. White and yellow draw repeated barely-shows-up complaints, and coverage reads thinner on deeper skin tones — the two spots where the pigment praise breaks down.
At $17.99 (as of August 2026), nothing in this price range puts more usable color in front of a Halloween, stage, or cosplay habit — as long as the setting powder comes along.